Man City transfer decisions on Foden, Walker, Steffen, more

Manchester City are undoubtedly in a fantastic place on the pitch and supervisor Pep Guardiola’s contract extension provides us a clearer view of the venture within the medium time period. We do not count on a giant summer season, however they’re going to have to make some strikes on the again, particularly in mild of the way in which he has reshuffled the formation this 12 months in addition to sure gamers getting older and maybe not becoming Pep’s plans the way in which they used to. Ilkay Gundogan will must be changed, and they should proceed their succession planning in attacking midfield, as Kevin De Bruyne and Bernardo Silva do not get youthful.

Their academy retains churning out children who could not have a future at City however can fetch appreciable transfer charges. Last season, they transferred 4 gamers — goalkeeper Gavin Bazunu, midfielder Romeo Lavia, winger Samuel Edozie and defender Juan Larios — to Southampton for a mixed whole of practically £40m. That’s necessary in balancing the books.

The foremost uncertainty going ahead, now that Guardiola has dedicated to the membership, is the Premier League cost for violations of economic sustainability laws. It may lead to a large wonderful and even relegation; it may result in a slap on the wrist or a full exoneration. We merely do not know and we do not know the timeline both. So whereas it stays effervescent within the background, it is not one thing you may think about when asking who to maintain, who to increase and who to maneuver on.

Editor’s observe: This is the primary of a collection of tales over the approaching weeks making use of the identical “who to keep, who to extend and who to move on” method to all the highest golf equipment within the Premier League and Europe.

---

GOALKEEPERS

Ederson (29 years previous, contract expires in 2026)

MARCOTTI: No motive to think about a brand new contract now; he is locked up they usually’re in place.

OGDEN: I agree, although the one factor I’d say is he has had his erratic moments this season.

Verdict: Keep

Stefan Ortega (30, 2025)

MARCOTTI: He has began many of the cup ties and a few Champions League group-stage video games and hasn’t executed a lot flawed. Presumably he is OK being a backup after a few years as a starter. There’s no want to increase his contract, for now a minimum of, since he is clearly not going to be Ederson’s long-term substitute.

Verdict: Keep, however don’t lengthen his deal

Zack Steffen (25, 2025)

OGDEN: He has been at Middlesbrough on mortgage and has had season within the Championship. Clearly, he desires to be a No. 1 with a view in direction of the 2026 World Cup, so the very best factor for City to do is money in. And Middlesbrough, particularly in the event that they get promoted, are prone to spend over market worth with a view to purchase him.

Verdict: Find him a brand new membership

Scott Carson (37, 2023)

MARCOTTI: Pep clearly likes having him already and if he is joyful to proceed because the No. 3 at this stage of his profession, there is no motive you would not preserve him since he does not value very a lot.

OGDEN: He’s type of just like the fortunate cat within the dressing room.

Verdict: Keep and lengthen his deal

---

DEFENDERS

Ruben Dias (25 years previous, contract expires in 2027)

OGDEN: He’s the appropriate age and regardless of being injured, I believe he is nonetheless their finest defender.

Verdict: Keep

Nathan Ake (28, 2025)

OGDEN: He’s versatile and has been good this season, however he did battle final season. I’d wait earlier than enthusiastic about extending his time at City, particularly since he’ll be 30 when his contract is up.

MARCOTTI: He’s been superb this season and matches this type of play nicely. I would not rush into negotiations simply but, however I’m wonderful with giving him a one-year extension with a pleasant wage bump. Especially because you could be dropping a number of guys on the again.

Verdict: Keep, however wait to increase his deal

John Stones (28, 2026)

MARCOTTI: It’s sort of surprising to assume that he has been on the membership seven years and solely began lower than half (47.2%) of City’s league video games. He has had accidents and numerous ups and downs. When he is good, he is superb, however with the three years left on his deal, there is no actual have to do something.

Verdict: Keep

Aymeric Laporte (28, 2025)

OGDEN: He was an everyday final 12 months and this season has hardly performed. I’m unsure how nicely he will get on with Pep. This is the time to switch him with a youthful model.

Verdict: Let him discover a new membership

Manuel Akanji (27, 2027)

MARCOTTI: He’s locked right into a long-term deal and has been one of many successes of the season for me, particularly contemplating his transfer price. It’s attention-grabbing as a result of he was a extremely touted teenager who become an inconsistent professional at Dortmund. But on this surroundings, he has been very stable.

Verdict: Keep

Sergio Gomez (22, 2026)

OGDEN: He hasn’t performed a lot, however there aren’t that many good left-backs on the market. Keep him as a squad participant.

MARCOTTI: Even with Oleksandr Zinchenko gone after which Joao Cancelo seemingly shifting on, he has had little or no enjoying time. At his age, when you fee him, he must play and, particularly with the set-up this season, I’m unsure that is going to occur. I’d look to mortgage him.

Verdict: Keep, however ship on mortgage for some expertise

Benjamin Mendy (28, 2023)

OGDEN: His contract is up, and his retrial is in the summer. This one is apparent.

Verdict: Release him

Kyle Walker (32, 2024)

OGDEN: He’s 33 in the summertime. I do not see any motive to maintain him, so that you may as nicely attempt to transfer him on. Someone will spend handsomely with a view to purchase him.

MARCOTTI: You’re not going to increase his contract at his age, so City may as nicely money in. Especially for the reason that present formation they’re utilizing works wonderful with out him.

Verdict: Let him discover a new membership

Rico Lewis (18, 2024)

MARCOTTI: He has had his moments since breaking into the City first-team, and he is younger sufficient that you just need to lengthen him. Maybe he’ll be a squad participant subsequent season, perhaps you mortgage him. Either approach, he is an asset.

Verdict: Keep and lengthen his contact

Joao Cancelo (28, 2027)

OGDEN: You want to maneuver him on. I can not consider any examples of the previous the place Guardiola has fallen out with somebody and brought him again.

MARCOTTI: I’d attempt to restore the connection. He has not had a good time at Bayern and he has a giant contract so he’ll onerous to shift on a everlasting transfer except you mortgage him once more. I simply assume he is so gifted, you must give it a shot. And if it does not work, mortgage him once more in January.”

Verdict: Split (let him go/keep)

Issa Kabore (21, 2025)

MARCOTTI: He’s still young and has backed up Jonathan Clauss most of the season at Marseille, but unless you get an offer for him, I’d keep him and evaluate him in the summer, especially if Walker and/or Joao Cancelo go. You can then decide what to do.

Verdict: Keep and reevaluate over the summer

Yan Couto (20, 2025)

MARCOTTI: He was considered a very promising prospect, but he’s struggled this season at Girona. If you’re going to bring back one of your on-loan right-backs, I think you go with Kabore.

Verdict: Loan out

---

MIDFIELDERS

Rodri (26 years old, contract expires in 2027)

OGDEN: He’s the best holding midfielder in the Premier League. It’s a no-brainer.

Verdict: Keep

Kalvin Phillips (27, 2028)

MARCOTTI: I think he has contributed very little this year, but with that sort of contract (reportedly over $7m per year), you’re going to struggle to find a new club. It’s one of those where you put your faith in Guardiola’s ability to help him settle and provide cover for Rodri.

OGDEN: If they sign Jude Bellingham or someone of that caliber, then you let Phillips go even at a loss, because he’s never going to play. You’ll find someone who would take him and pay a big fee for him. The Premier League is awash with clubs that have more money than sense. For example, I think City could get their money back by offering him to, say, West Ham if they shift Declan Rice this summer.

Verdict: Split (let him go/keep)

Maximo Perrone (20, 2028)

MARCOTTI: He has played 22 minutes of senior football this season and he has a long-term deal, so loan him out and get him playing time.

Verdict: Loan him out

Ilkay Gundogan (32, 2023)

OGDEN: They tried to offer him a new deal, but he wants to move on after seven years at the club, which is understandable.

Verdict: Release this summer

Kevin De Bruyne (31, 2025)

OGDEN: I think he looks a little worn down after so many games over the years, and he is getting older. See how things go and maybe move him on next summer if he wants to go.

MARCOTTI: I think given what he has done for the club, you give him a bit of leeway. He has a slightly lesser role this season, but that’s fine. See where you are next summer in terms of an extension, maybe a one-year deal, given he turns 34 in 2025.

Verdict: Keep

Bernardo Silva (28, 2025)

OGDEN: I think he feels a bit of a cog in a machine. He has wanted to leave for the past few summers and I imagine it will be the same this summer, but who is going to pay his fee and his wages?

MARCOTTI: Guardiola has shown he doesn’t keep guys around against their will, so if he’s still there, it’s likely because there isn’t a more appealing option for him that works in terms of wages and fees. I think you sit tight, and I think that suits him too. If he decides he wants to go, a year from now maybe he can move on a reduced fee. Or, two years from now, as a 30-year-old free agent, would be even better.

Verdict: Keep

Yangel Herrera (25, 2024)

MARCOTTI: He has basically been on loan since 2017. He was at Girona most recently and didn’t really make a splash. Get what you can for the Venezuelan international with a year left on his deal and move on.

Verdict: Find him a new club

---

FORWARDS

Cole Palmer (20 years old, contract expires in 2026)

MARCOTTI: He’s young, he’s a squad player, he’s fine. He may not grow into a star, but he understands what Guardiola wants from him and he’s ready to step in now and then. You need guys like him to round out the squad.

Verdict: Keep

Phil Foden (22, 2027)

OGDEN: He hasn’t performed rather a lot this season and has had accidents. If that carries on, who is aware of? Compare him to Bukayo Saka. If he’d been at Arsenal, he’d be enjoying a far higher function. He’s 22, which is not that younger anymore. If his function does not change, he could need to transfer on.

MARCOTTI: I’m a giant Foden man. He has slipped down the pecking order this season, and I believe subsequent 12 months can be key for him. Can he perhaps contribute more from central positions? Can he regain a spot out vast? If it is not working for him, you may consider shifting him on — and he can consider shifting on — subsequent summer season. He’ll nonetheless have three years left on his deal and can boast a ton of worth available in the market.

Verdict: Keep

Jack Grealish (27, 2027)

OGDEN: He has had an excellent season, rising into the participant Guardiola wished. You preserve him. Easy.

Verdict: Keep

Riyad Mahrez (32, 2025)

OGDEN: I believe he is been one among their finest gamers this season, together with Haaland and Rodri. But at his age, you are not going to increase his deal. That mentioned, his contract means you may make a call subsequent summer season.

MARCOTTI: I agree, not least as a result of you will have built-in options in Julian Alvarez and Foden who can play his function.

Verdict: Keep

Erling Haaland (22, 2027)

OGDEN: We assume there is a launch clause, as a result of it is onerous to see his brokers agreeing to maneuver to City with out one. He had all of the leverage, for a begin, and he had such clauses at Borussia Dortmund and Salzburg. Nobody has confirmed that it exists, nonetheless. That mentioned, if it is there, you’d need a new deal for him, perhaps with a pay increase, that removes it. Of course, that is based mostly on him agreeing to it.

MARCOTTI: He does not strike me as a man who’s motivated by cash or actually cares how a lot he makes. Or a man who will throw a strop if he feels underpaid. And yeah, I do not purchase that Kane-for-Haaland principle.

Verdict: Keep, discover a approach to lengthen his contract

Julian Alvarez (23, 2028)

MARCOTTI: They simply prolonged his contract and gave him a bump, so clearly he is a preserve.

Verdict: Keep

Nahuel Bustos (24, 2025)

MARCOTTI: He scored objectives for Girona within the second division two years in the past however has had a troublesome time since then, struggling on mortgage at Sao Paulo and with Talleres, the place he began out. It looks like a descending spiral right here. I believe you progress him when you can; if not, you let him go on mortgage once more.

Verdict: Find him a brand new membership, both on mortgage or a everlasting deal